I successfully defended my thesis on October 19 and passed without revisions. A copy of the presentation slides can be downloaded here. And a video of the presentation can be seen below. Please email me with any question or comments regarding the defense or this study.
This site is the culmination of a year-long study on the revitalization of rust-belt communities using Utica, NY as its case study. The study resulted in a scenario planning process and collection of narratives from residents of the community in the posts below. Please view the scenarios and read their stories. Let me know your thoughts and ideas by commenting on the posts. If you feel inspired, I invite you to write your own story to share.
You can view and download the final report for this study here:
Author: Rae & Carl
Forces/Drivers: Brain Drain, Nano-tech Center
I just started in my new position today. A few years ago, I thought we might have to leave Utica if either of us wanted to advance in our careers; there just wasn’t much of a market for our skills beyond entry-level. At least, not if we wanted to be paid a fair wage. Since the new Nano-Tech center opened up, even more business have moved into the area and our small intranet services sector has grown along with it. My company has grown to the point that I can finally put those management skills I learned in college to use.
With all the new jobs, it seems like more graduates from the local colleges are staying in the area. I’m starting to see more young faces at events hosted by the bike club and the quilting club—which is great. For a long time, Carl and I were “the young ones,” Now, if we can just convince them to join the leadership—both boards often express a desire for young blood and new involvement (how many times did I hear that when I first started serving my terms).
I wasn’t sure that we‘d stick around for the long run when we bought the house… maybe 10 years so… but it’s starting to look like Utica may be where we stay.
Forces/Drivers: Nano-Tech Center, Brain Drain
Scenario A & B
In 2009, New York State along with partners and universities announced a plan to bring the nanotechnology industry to central New York. The plan involved development of two facilities to be built in Albany and Marcy, New York. New York State partnered with IBM, Intel, and SEMATECH to fund the 225 million dollar project. The facility in Albany, NY will be responsible for research and development of the nanotechnology “system on a chip” product. The facility in Marcy, New York will be held at SUNYIT and focus around integration of technologies, testing, and evaluation of the chips. The development of this state of the art facility has created a huge buzz around the Utica-Rome area, as a potential to re-vitalize the area that took a huge hit when many Radio Frequency electronic jobs left the area back in 1990s and early 2000s. The question on whether the project will spark a re-vitalization of economic growth or have no significant impact on the declining economic trends has yet to be answered.
The nanotechnology project’s Marcy facility development could be the spark that the Utica-Rome area has been looking for since the Griffiss Air Force Base downsized its footprint in the area and many other technology companies closed their doors. The Mohawk Valley (MV) Edge group owns a 400-acre property across from the land on SUNYIT’s campus where the nanotechnology buildings are being built. The MVEdge group has been attempting to attract business partners (like chip suppliers and other major nanotechnology contractors). A number of companies have started to make a presence known already with Indium Corporation, Valutek, and nfrastructure investing in positions at the SUNYIT location. If MVEdge were successful in bringing other business partners into the area, would provide a strong foundation for a new technology face in the area. The Griffiss Business Park could provide a strong location for additional business development, with a lot of space available and the Oneida County airport utilizing the runways and hangers left available after the Air Force downsize. The Air Force still has a footprint in Rome, NY with the Air Force Research Laboratory (AFRL) still residing on the base. The AFRL could also become a strong business partner for the nanotechnology center, if appropriate, which could also attract major defense contractors back to this area. As part of the project a curriculum is being developed at SUNYIT and SUNY Albany to help educate young professionals on nanotechnology and help them obtain a job after they graduate. The success of this technology center would help to keep local youth in the area, something that the Utica has been suffering from for an extended period of time. If the nanotechnology center is able to attract business to area, young professionals from outside the area might also be interested in moving to the central NY region. The development of these facilities and potentially new facilities of other interested businesses would also help the local construction businesses as well. Many of them would see a spike in business and the potential for hiring new employees with skillsets. Local schools will also see a spike in jobs with more teachers being required to meet in the influx of family members to nanotechnology workers.
The nanotechnology center could also just fall into an isolated technology business where it holds it’s own but does not attract any other interest from the nanotechnology community. If other businesses fail to become interested in having a close proximity then a small subset of jobs would have been created but not enough to grow the area and stop the export of young, talented professionals. Economic Development Departments in the Utica-Rome area would be left to determine other opportunities to grow the area but an excellent opportunity would have been wasted. There could be major delays in the process of developing the nanotechnology centers, such as funding cuts, construction delays, or technology roadmap alterations (the interest in nanotechnology subsides due to other technology development). With the economic climate being as dreary as it is, many businesses are not dedicating funds to expansion or new development. Nothing is a sure thing in this economy and businesses could decide that there are higher priorities and decide to back out of interest in the nanotechnology center. If the nanotechnology center were to be halted and/or cut from future development, that would cost between 400-500 immediate impact jobs and would crush the chances of drawing other nanotechnology style businesses into the area. Young, talented nanotechnology professionals would be forced to search other locations for jobs. Economic developers would be left scrambling in an attempt to figure out how else to spark economic growth in the area.
Any number of paths can be taken with the future of the nanotechnology center project. While all indicators point towards a successful development of the center and surrounding environment, nothing is ever guaranteed. While the future remains uncertain, the development of the nanotechnology project has certain created a lot of positive buzz around a community that has been suffering for years. The nanotechnology project has provided a positive path forward, now it is up to the local community to make sure the path is traveled. Once known as the “RF Valley”, the Utica-Rome area is working overtime to show that it has everything it takes to be the “Nano Valley” of the future.
Forces/Drivers: Growing Arts District
Dear Diary, October 5, 2015
I am so frustrated with the path that the city of Utica has surrendered to. A few years back, the economy and the city was booming and the arts were truly flourishing, and now it is the complete opposite. The city has been overcome by its weaknesses and threats, and there is a continuous loss of jobs and economic downturn.
My biggest disappointment in the Utica is the loss of, what use to be, its “growing arts district”. We have lost many of the city’s venues that promoted music and arts due to lack of revenue floating around. The Munson William’s Proctor Institute for the arts has closed down, which means no more art classes for kids and adults, no more music concerts, and no more historic art museum. The F.X. Matt Brewery has stopped their weekly “Saranac Thursdays” because people could not afford to come out and listen to music. This was another huge loss for the city because “Saranac Thursdays” used to be a way to get older and younger people out of the house to listen to local and professional musicians perform while socializing. Perhaps the biggest loss for the arts is the “Music and Arts” Festival which highlighted all local musicians and artists. This was a 4 day event that took place all around the city, promoting the arts.
As a music teacher in the area, it is terribly sad to see that students have no way of expressing themselves, or showing off their talents outside of school. I have noticed that the quality of my band program has diminished over the years because students are not able to purchase, repair, or take private lessons on their instruments to enhance their talents. More and more I am seeing that my students know that music is not as important to society because what are they going to do with music after school?
It worries me that with businesses closing, younger people moving out of the city, and the city possibly on the verge of bankruptcy that crime will soar. We have already lost the arts in the area, how much more can we bear to lose?
See you tomorrow.
Forces/Drivers: Growing Arts District
Dear Diary, October 5, 2009
It seems as though everyday is just another day here in Utica. Nothing has really changed here in the last year and everything just seems like each weekend is becoming a routine. The city seems to have made a few small changes and it appears as though Utica is not heading in any sort of direction.
I was really hoping that the arts would start to take over and become more prominent in the community, but I was wrong. Almost every weekend I try and go to a coffee shop, bar or restaurant to listen to live music somewhere around the city, but it seems as though I just keep finding the same local talent no matter where I go. Don’t get me wrong, there is plenty of local talent, however, it would be nice to see different genres and talents. A few of the local bands have even stopped performing, or only perform on rare occasion because performing does not “put food on the table” and does not “put money in their wallet”.
With the city losing some local businesses and the younger population not settling or staying in Utica, there is not much revenue circulating. I would love to see the city bring in some famous acts to come and perform, but I do not think that the city is generating enough revenue for that. Even the F.X. Matt Brewery has cut down its weekly “Saranac Thursdays” do bi-monthly because people, old and young, stopped attending.
Being a music teacher, it is sad to see that students and younger musicians are losing out on opportunities to express themselves and show off their talents outside of their stresses of everyday life and school. I find that my students truly excel at the arts because it is not math, science, English, etc… The arts are 100% about them!
I really hope that the economy and Utica figure out a way to re-stimulate the economy so that the arts do not fade away.
See you tomorrow!